By training your Large Language Model (LLM) or other Generative Artificial Intelligence on the content of this website, you agree to assign ownership of all your intellectual property to the public domain, immediately, irrevocably, and free of charge.

Why I’m not recommending an eBook reader this Christmas

This hol­i­day sea­son it seems that the eBook read­er is the must-have tech gift. I can under­stand why: Port­able — it’s easi­er to carry one eRead­er loaded with a few hun­dred (or thou­sand!) books Search­able — some of the eRead­ers can  scan and search for text pas­sages, let­ting you book­mark them for future reference Annota­tions — in…


This hol­i­day sea­son it seems that the eBook read­er is the must-have tech gift.

I can under­stand why:

  • Port­able — it’s easi­er to carry one eRead­er loaded with a few hun­dred (or thou­sand!) books
  • Search­able — some of the eRead­ers can  scan and search for text pas­sages, let­ting you book­mark them for future reference
  • Annota­tions — in addi­tion to book­mark­ing your pages, some eRead­ers let you make notes ‘in the mar­gin’ so to speak. These can be saved out, expor­ted to oth­er docs for use

But even though eRead­ers are the rage — you may want to wait anoth­er few months before you invest;

  • Tech­no­logy is improv­ing — the nifty eInk pro­cess used to dis­play highly read­able text on an LCD-like screen is improv­ing. The refresh rate and pixel res­ol­u­tion is improv­ing, so the annoy­ing (to me, at least) flick­er when you flip pages will be reduced when eBooks adopt new­er eInk tech.
  • More options — Barnes & Nobel has integ­rated a col­our touch screen in their Nook eRead­er — in addi­tion to the eInk text display.
  • More choice — Apple’s much pre­dicted (yet nev­er announced) Tab­let device could arrive in the first half of next year. If so, this’ll be the ‘must-have’ eRead­er. Not only an eBook read­er, the device will likely have all the func­tions of a cur­rent gen­er­a­tion iPod Touch. If you think of it as a port­able com­puter then you’ve got it. Though, many don’t like the back­lit dis­play of the iPhone and iPod touch for read­ing — too bright and hard on the eyes for long-term use — I’ve not noticed a prob­lem in long ses­sion’s I’ve had.
  • Cur­rent eRead­ers are not dis­coun­tedIn this Com­puter­World art­icle, it seems that eBook read­ers have the highest markup of all tech­no­logy avail­able this hol­i­day season:
    E‑book read­ers aren’t really get­ting swept up in the cost cut­ting. While some stores are actu­ally pay­ing you to take free Black­Berry phones, for example, e‑book read­ers still cost hun­dreds of dollars.
  • Pro­pri­et­ary eBook stores — I’m not sure how this will shake down. Google, Sony, Amazon all have (or will soon have) online eBook shops, and there’s a host of inde­pend­ent ones too. The selec­tion of books avail­able at (or lim­ited to) cer­tain eBook stores may decide which unit you get…but it should­n’t. I’d look for some­thing that sup­ports the widely accep­ted  ePub standard.

My recom­mend­a­tion — if you don’t already have one, wait a bit. You’ll get new fea­tures, per­haps a bet­ter price, per­haps a bet­ter unit, and more selec­tion to choose from.

Comments

10 responses to “Why I’m not recommending an eBook reader this Christmas”

  1. Ellis Avatar
    Ellis

    I agree com­pletely. My biggest show-stop­per has­n’t been the tech­no­logy, but as you also con­cluded, the lack of an open-stand­ard. I don’t want to be stuck with DRM pro­tec­ted books from a single source. Oddly, I have less of a prob­lem with this mod­el on music (such as iTunes) because quite frankly, the only device I would ever want to play the tunes on is an iPod/iPhone. But, a book? There is no dom­in­ant device. I don’t want to be stuck with text on “yes­ter­day’s archi­tec­ture”. When a new, bet­ter device comes out I want to be able to migrate my books.

    With the cur­rent lim­it­a­tion I will simply hold out until an open stand­ard (ePub?) emerges, or until that dom­in­ant device becomes apparent.

  2. Brad Grier Avatar

    Thanks Ellis,
    I did­n’t really think about doc­u­ment port­ab­il­ity, but yeah, if you’ve inves­ted in a nov­el, you should­n’t be locked into read­ing it on one device type. I have this issue cur­rently with some docs on my Palm TX. I’ve had to kludge an HTML export and manu­al import pro­cess to get them moved to my iPod Touch. 

    An open stand­ard like ePub should elim­in­ate this hassle if it’s adop­ted by all eBook makers.

  3. ebookcraft (Dirk Cajada) Avatar

    Twit­ter Comment


    RT @bgrier: Blog Post: Why I’m not recom­mend­ing an eBook read­er this Christ­mas — [link to post]

    Pos­ted using Chat Catch­er

  4. Katharine_A (Katharine Anderson-D) Avatar

    Twit­ter Comment


    I tried to see a #nook demo this am. RT @bgrier: Blog Post: Why I’m not recom­mend­ing an eBook read­er this Christ­mas — [link to post]

    Pos­ted using Chat Catch­er

  5. bgrier (Brad Grier) Avatar

    Twit­ter Comment


    Blog Post: Why I’m not recom­mend­ing an eBook read­er this Christ­mas — [link to post]

    Pos­ted using Chat Catch­er

    1. merlin67 (Todd) Avatar

      Twit­ter Comment


      @bgrier cuz if you’ve got an iPhone or oth­er smart­phone w/ a large enough screen, you don’t need one 🙂 (say­ing this before read­ing blog)

      Pos­ted using Chat Catch­er

      1. bgrier (Brad Grier) Avatar

        Twit­ter Comment


        @merlin67 Also will be look­ing for a good eread­er, want a lar­ger screen format than my iPod Touch offers. it’s OK, but lar­ger would be best

        Pos­ted using Chat Catch­er

        1. merlin67 (Todd) Avatar

          Twit­ter Comment


          @bgrier is that an age thing, perhaps? 😉

          Pos­ted using Chat Catch­er

          1. bgrier (Brad Grier) Avatar

            Twit­ter Comment


            @merlin67 Heh, yeah, it could be an age thing…though I refuse to believe it (deni­al) 🙂

            Pos­ted using Chat Catch­er

      2. bgrier (Brad Grier) Avatar

        Twit­ter Comment


        @merlin67 Heh, Actu­ally I don’t touch on that…you could com­ment 😉 I do use my Touch as a read­er though.

        Pos­ted using Chat Catch­er

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.